they are not referenced here. I opened several times a topic, but no answers.
These coins must be listed as separate country, or under Ethiopia. but someone must to create this or that..
300 countries
300 positive trades
next mission 400 Silver club (397-400) and 10000 coin collection (long way to go)---- already have 10000 coins to trade
The mission I have been thinking about though is how hard it would be to do perhaps 100 KM1,s- would that be possible -'------------just checked according to numista there is 239 in catalogue and I only have 61 so just a wild dream I guess
Please be informed that Northern Mariana Islands will be removed as there is no proof they're at least NCLTs, according to Jarcek. So we consider them as fantasy coins for now unless we have a contrary proof.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Taking Northern Mariana Islands as a country is like lying into your own pocket, I wonder how it managed to stay in the country list for so long.
Anyway, while not feeling sorry for anything, you will still be compensated by creating Duchy of Courland sometime in the future. (A real country this time!)
Real country ? Like I wrote in another post, Courland was part of Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth, so maybe lets make ALL fief the "real" countries ?
Look on the reverse of the coin, whose coat of arms appears there (Eagle and Pogoń)
And what about Teutonic Order ? There is Malta Order, so why not Teutonic Order ? They still exist untill now.
It is still an open issue. Point is that there are many cases like this, which were even less independent.
Estonia and Livonia and Siberia are great examples. But lets not polute this thread. We can discuss it elsewhere.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "chomp-master"Please be informed that Northern Mariana Islands will be removed as there is no proof they're at least NCLTs, according to Jarcek. So we consider them as fantasy coins for now unless we have a contrary proof.
That's good- now get rid of those other US "colonies" with token coins like Palau and Marshall islands and even American Samoa
We already stated, checking online Krause book of 2016, that US Samoa are considered as a local NCLT currency (by the Governor's proclamation) like did Andorra before having their own euro coinage. They won't be deleted.
Marshall Islands and Palau are US equivalents of Cook Islands for NZ, for example.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
That's crazy comparing cook island to the U.S. Palau and Marshall the Cook islands have there own circulating coins The 2 USA territory nation's only have fantasy coins there lies the difference
Quote: "muzz0000"That's crazy comparing cook island to the U.S. Palau and Marshall the Cook islands have there own circulating coins The 2 USA territory nation's only have fantasy coins there lies the difference
If you are talking about Palau and the Marshall Islands (hard to tell because the punctuation seems to be missing), they are not territory nations. They are full nations who are in a Compact of Free Association with the United States.
Chomp master you are incorrect. The tokens of American Samoa were issued outside of USLaw. There is no ambiguity here. They are not nclt. They are fantasy at best. They were made with no legal authority by a government that did not have that authority. Your opinion does not override the law if the United States.
Library Media Specialist, columnist, collector, and gardener...
If they bypassed the federal law to create a local alternative currency by par with the legal one, this is not our problem. The important thing is: did the local government REALLY asked for them?
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
The territory quarter program of the US did not include a quarter for Marshall Islands or Palau because they are not territories of the US. A quarter was made with N. Marianna Islands because it is a territory of the US. Google is a search engine, not law.
Library Media Specialist, columnist, collector, and gardener...
I disagree chomp-master. The law must be more important than your opinion. Especially in this situation. The token issue of American Samoa is extra-legal. the token is there. The token was made. you can touch this token. But it has no supporting law. There is not even law that supports local issue of currency at par with a federal level in the USA. This issue is Fantasy. It is not in the published hard copy of Krause 2016 catalog, it is in the Krause fantasy catalog. For you to call this an nclt is disappointing. It could be the illustration of the word fantasy in a coin term dictionary.
Library Media Specialist, columnist, collector, and gardener...
Ehm, why you did not said this earlier? If Krause 2016 did designate them as X already, and not KM, scan or photo us the page, and I will move them right away.
(I have 2014 edition - I know, shameful) and they still have KMs there.
Quote: "Oklahoman"Chomp master you are incorrect. The tokens of American Samoa were issued outside of US Law. There is no ambiguity here. They are not nclt. They are fantasy at best. They were made with no legal authority by a government that did not have that authority. Your opinion does not override the law if the United States.
That is not technically correct. The U.S. approved the American Samoa constitution, the constitution that was enacted at the time the coins were minted protects American Samoa Indigenous rights, way of life, etc. So since the coins were approved by the native governor of the islands, you can argue they are legit. It is similar to the way Native American tribes mint money on/for their reservations. Krause even has two of these tribes listed as a country in their most recent catalog.
I also just checked 2016 KM catalog and they are still listed on page 57.
And also in NGC World Coin Price Guide and Values. So American Samoa won't be removed. Debate closed for now.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
It will remain closed until Krause would move it to eXonumia. There are other countries which currencies are/were considered illegal when minted, no matter why, so legality of this coinage can't count as a single argument.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
The debate is closed. When i checked my krause of 2016 and saw its inclusion i calledmy friend Tom Michael at Krause who has replaced George. He said it was reincluded because of research by Gunthor Schoen. So i spoke with the office of Amata Radewagon, the member at large from American Samoa to the US House of Representatives. They said that the 1988 issues are legal, but that coin right of territories are rescinded since then. So only the 1988 are legal. I use this occasion to sauce up and eat a healthy serving of crow. And yes. Some sovereign tribes have issued nclt, so there should be some new countries..Indian States perhaps?
Library Media Specialist, columnist, collector, and gardener...
Quote: "Oklahoman"The debate is closed. When i checked my krause of 2016 and saw its inclusion i calledmy friend Tom Michael at Krause who has replaced George. He said it was reincluded because of research by Gunthor Schoen. So i spoke with the office of Amata Radewagon, the member at large from American Samoa to the US House of Representatives. They said that the 1988 issues are legal, but that coin right of territories are rescinded since then. So only the 1988 are legal. I use this occasion to sauce up and eat a healthy serving of crow. And yes. Some sovereign tribes have issued nclt, so there should be some new countries..Indian States perhaps?
Thank you for chasing down the facts even when they didn't lead where you thought. Respect levels rise.
Quote: "Oklahoman"The debate is closed. When i checked my krause of 2016 and saw its inclusion i calledmy friend Tom Michael at Krause who has replaced George. He said it was reincluded because of research by Gunthor Schoen. So i spoke with the office of Amata Radewagon, the member at large from American Samoa to the US House of Representatives. They said that the 1988 issues are legal, but that coin right of territories are rescinded since then. So only the 1988 are legal. I use this occasion to sauce up and eat a healthy serving of crow. And yes. Some sovereign tribes have issued nclt, so there should be some new countries..Indian States perhaps?
Thank you for chasing down the facts even when they didn't lead where you though. Respect levels rise.
Quote: "jadejackal that's good matter closed thankyou for your input OKI-- good to see someone is capable of doing proper research"
Quote: "Oklahoman"The debate is closed. When i checked my krause of 2016 and saw its inclusion i calledmy friend Tom Michael at Krause who has replaced George. He said it was reincluded because of research by Gunthor Schoen. So i spoke with the office of Amata Radewagon, the member at large from American Samoa to the US House of Representatives. They said that the 1988 issues are legal, but that coin right of territories are rescinded since then. So only the 1988 are legal. I use this occasion to sauce up and eat a healthy serving of crow. And yes. Some sovereign tribes have issued nclt, so there should be some new countries..Indian States perhaps?
Thank you for chasing down the facts even when they didn't lead where you though. Respect levels rise.
Quote: "Hamletmaschine"Would it be possible to reach 300 countries if you only collect silver? I think I'm at 76 countries right now, and could easily reach 100 if I spent some more money, but 300?
DO you guys think it is possible? I have over 250 countries, but only put my silver and gold into numista and those only add to 336 coins and 51 countries...
I collect anything: If it's Italian or Italian states i collect it even more!
Just an annoucement: *Exonumia* will show up in the country list, and also in the country count. It is already been reported to Xavier to erase it from country count as are tokens already. So please disregard it when counting countries.
Quote: "Hamletmaschine"Would it be possible to reach 300 countries if you only collect silver? I think I'm at 76 countries right now, and could easily reach 100 if I spent some more money, but 300?
DO you guys think it is possible? I have over 250 countries, but only put my silver and gold into numista and those only add to 336 coins and 51 countries...
I think it is, but I think it'll be really expensive between NCLTs, Antique & Medievals,...
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Hamletmaschine"Would it be possible to reach 300 countries if you only collect silver? I think I'm at 76 countries right now, and could easily reach 100 if I spent some more money, but 300?
DO you guys think it is possible? I have over 250 countries, but only put my silver and gold into numista and those only add to 336 coins and 51 countries...
I think it is, but I think it'll be really expensive between NCLTs, Antique & Medievals,...
Modern NCLT is usually no problem, it's more expensive to get hold of pre-ww2 silver coins from Albania, Danzig etc. But how many countries are there that never issued any silver coins at all?
Hello , you're right to be jealous of us. It is much easier for us to go " to the source" to find what we seek . And everything is close! It is not for nothing that Europe is nicknamed " the old continent " ( A majority of countries we collect is of European origin )
Quote: "Hamletmaschine"Would it be possible to reach 300 countries if you only collect silver? I think I'm at 76 countries right now, and could easily reach 100 if I spent some more money, but 300?
DO you guys think it is possible? I have over 250 countries, but only put my silver and gold into numista and those only add to 336 coins and 51 countries...
I think it is, but I think it'll be really expensive between NCLTs, Antique & Medievals,...
Modern NCLT is usually no problem, it's more expensive to get hold of pre-ww2 silver coins from Albania, Danzig etc. But how many countries are there that never issued any silver coins at all?
Most of the old countries issued at least some circulating silver (though much of it would be quite rare and expensive). Most of the modern countries issued at least some silver NCLT (though, again, in many cases it is quite rare and expensive, and it might be hard to distinguish authentic NCLT from fantasy issues).
The problematic countries (that didn't make any silver) would mostly be those that existed briefly in the 20th century; there shouldn't be too many of those to make a 300 country set impossible in theory. (Though, as already mentioned, it would be extremely hard and expensive in practice!) I didn't check the entire list, but Bohemia and Moravia is the first such example alphabetically.
Incidentally, I just reached 100 countries in the entered part of my collection (though I mainly collect very cheap coins, so I have very little silver).
well done- i have about 5-6 to replace to have a pure 300 collection (no tokens, NCLT,or fantasy coins) Does anyone want to trade Fantasy /NCLT coins against countries i need---
I have to quit
Belarus km298
nuie x3 5 dollars
Tokelae $1 coin
St helena km9
in exchange for countries i do not have
can the referee for the Pacific islands check status of TOKELAE 1 dollar coins, i am sure they are only NCLT
just grabbed nice LIvonia coin off ebay double whammy (new country and 1 more silver) 302 in country collection and 399 in silver for less than $6.00 us inc postage-- I am happy ----------any more affordable countries I am missing??????
You're right, Lorraine is quite easy to catch, particularly billon coinage (billon = low silver amount)
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "muzz0000"any more affordable countries I am missing??????
Livonia isn't an affordable country
Please send us the link !
You might be interested by these easy to catch countries:
Islamic states (Muwahhid Almohade Dynasty)
Lorraine
Mexico - Revolutionary (ask Erdvilla )
Ruanda-Burundi
Spanish Netherlands
Yemen - People's Democratic Republic
Yemenite states
If he sends to Australia, he may do the same to NZ, that's close enough.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Just being curious - how do you do that? Getting new country every two days?
I usually have 10 or more winning bids per week on eBay and these new countries are part of the process. Things will be slowing down as the coins are starting to get more expensive. I won't add the NCLT or fantasy issuing countries to my total. As of today I have only 49 or so countries that I will seek and half of them are considered ancient.
won the Lorraine coin-just waiting for price of postagen -Thanks for your help guys - is this km74 and WHAT GRADE do you consider- I thought maybe F because great detail but chunks missing
Congratulations for your 1st Lorraine coin. Particularly knowing this coin was made during the de jure independance period of Lorraine.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
It contains silver, but a low amount (in that case: 1/6th), that's why we name this Billon
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Frenchlover"This coin
Now you should get for us coins for each of your countries
no I will leave to the europe guys to play with there fantasy coins- we actually do have one here in NZ called Riviera that has produced coins and banknotes- and I do not have any
There is no real limit to say when a coin with few silver becomes billon. For me, it would be like you, aka. less than a half. But some others may say less.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Maybe both Nepal and India (ancient) referees had a talk to split Nepal coinage from India. Even no news, I'm just making this supposition.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
If you really want to have them colourized, ask Xavier to merge these territories as part of USA, since its tokenization removed the territories from the catalog, unless they would come back as not simple tokens.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Frenchlover story of my life- won a LIvonia on ebay this morning and received a job lot containing over 20 this afternoon-- so far several km9 and km2 and alot to investigate!!! work work work"
Quote: "muzz0000"any more affordable countries I am missing??????
Livonia isn't an affordable country
Please send us the link !
You might be interested by these easy to catch countries:
Islamic states (Muwahhid Almohade Dynasty)
Lorraine
Mexico - Revolutionary (ask Erdvilla )
Ruanda-Burundi
Spanish Netherlands
Yemen - People's Democratic Republic
Yemenite states
And now, we welcome our first African member , numis4.
Who is living in a beautiful Algerian coastal city full of history and art, mixing Berber, Almohad, Spanish, French and Arabic influences.
And what was new on April ?
Creation of ** Exonumia **
eug got Numidia
jadejacka got Nepal (ancient) a new country!
Quote: "jelle"Maybe the 300 country club members should get a badge on their profile :p, if they proof they have 300 countrys
I'm at a loss, how would anyone actually prove what they have? Whether it be 300 countries, 10,000 coins, 300 silver coins. Photos would not prove anything, they can be faked along with the catalog entries. I'm sure that most people on this site report what they have because they are honest people. Besides, why does anyone really care what someone else has.
Quote: "jelle"Maybe the 300 country club members should get a badge on their profile :p, if they proof they have 300 countrys
I'm at a loss, how would anyone actually prove what they have? Whether it be 300 countries, 10,000 coins, 300 silver coins. Photos would not prove anything, they can be faked along with the catalog entries. I'm sure that most people on this site report what they have because they are honest people. Besides, why does anyone really care what someone else has.
Because it makes life interesting setting yourself goals i.e 300 country club- 400 silver club-300 trades ( this can be proved by checking profile)) - maybe we should check with members partners, they will always complain about how much we are spending
I have been lucky as being only one of a handful of traders from NZ, many people have traded and want to trade with me---and our standard postage is so cheap- less than $2.00 us for 200gms anywhere So i have built up a very nice world wide collection for very little outlay- made alot of friends and a couple that are not i guess---just a whole lot of fun
Quote: "jelle"Maybe the 300 country club members should get a badge on their profile :p, if they proof they have 300 countrys
I'm at a loss, how would anyone actually prove what they have? Whether it be 300 countries, 10,000 coins, 300 silver coins. Photos would not prove anything, they can be faked along with the catalog entries. I'm sure that most people on this site report what they have because they are honest people. Besides, why does anyone really care what someone else has.
Because it makes life interesting setting yourself goals i.e 300 country club- 400 silver club-300 trades ( this can be proved by checking profile)) - maybe we should check with members partners, they will always complain about how much we are spending
I have been lucky as being only one of a handful of traders from NZ, many people have traded and want to trade with me---and our standard postage is so cheap- less than $2.00 us for 200gms anywhere So i have built up a very nice world wide collection for very little outlay- made alot of friends and a couple that are not i guess---just a whole lot of fun
What I meant about "why does anyone care" did not mean one's self but why would someone else care what you have and why would they want proof of a claim. Your profile does not actually prove anything, we take you at your word.
Quote: "muzz0000 messed up badly cutting and pasting"
Quote: "SRV5490"
Quote: "jelle"Maybe the 300 country club members should get a badge on their profile :p, if they proof they have 300 countrys
I'm at a loss, how would anyone actually prove what they have? Whether it be 300 countries, 10,000 coins, 300 silver coins. Photos would not prove anything, they can be faked along with the catalog entries. I'm sure that most people on this site report what they have because they are honest people. Besides, why does anyone really care what someone else has.
Because it makes life interesting setting yourself goals i.e 300 country club- 400 silver club-300 trades ( this can be proved by checking profile)) - maybe we should check with members partners, they will always complain about how much we are spending
I have been lucky as being only one of a handful of traders from NZ, many people have traded and want to trade with me---and our standard postage is so cheap- less than $2.00 us for 200gms anywhere So i have built up a very nice world wide collection for very little outlay- made alot of friends and a couple that are not i guess---just a whole lot of fun
Quote: "muzz0000 messed up badly cutting and pasting"
Quote: "SRV5490"
Quote: "jelle"Maybe the 300 country club members should get a badge on their profile :p, if they proof they have 300 countrys
I'm at a loss, how would anyone actually prove what they have? Whether it be 300 countries, 10,000 coins, 300 silver coins. Photos would not prove anything, they can be faked along with the catalog entries. I'm sure that most people on this site report what they have because they are honest people. Besides, why does anyone really care what someone else has.
Because it makes life interesting setting yourself goals i.e 300 country club- 400 silver club-300 trades ( this can be proved by checking profile)) - maybe we should check with members partners, they will always complain about how much we are spending
I have been lucky as being only one of a handful of traders from NZ, many people have traded and want to trade with me---and our standard postage is so cheap- less than $2.00 us for 200gms anywhere So i have built up a very nice world wide collection for very little outlay- made alot of friends and a couple that are not i guess---just a whole lot of fun
I repeat, how would anyone actually prove what they have? Your profile is not proof of anything.
Why would they need to prove what they have? The club was set up for fun and as a place for people with similar goals to chat and compare notes. There's no financial or material benefit to being a member, there's no increase in power or prestige by being a member. Why would someone lie to be included, necessitating the need to prove that they have 300 countries?
Thanks neilithic, that's pretty much what I thought I was trying to get across but I guess I messed up. Crossing borders can be tough....or interesting.
It might actually be a pretty cool idea to have a section on your profile where you can add images of badges to show what you collect and to mark when you pass milestones e.g. 50 countries, 100 countries, 200 countries, 300 countries, 1000 coins, 2500 coins, 5000 coins, 7500 coins, African coin collector, British coin collector, Euro coin collector, USA coin collector, etc
That would be great. Over 40 years ago I belonged to a couple of SWLing or DXing clubs (shortwave listening or long distance listening) using a shortwave/AM communications receiver. They would have achievment awards for the number of countries, stations, countries within a certain continent, etc. It made the hobby a lot of fun.
Quote: "SRV5490"That would be great. Over 40 years ago I belonged to a couple of SWLing or DXing clubs (shortwave listening or long distance listening) using a shortwave/AM communications receiver. They would have achievment awards for the number of countries, stations, countries within a certain continent, etc. It made the hobby a lot of fun.
I think the numista club idea would be the same. Make it all a lot of fun establish goals.recognise achievements. And build up trust between traders
What's new on May ?
Eug is once again getting the leading edge with an ancient Hispania coin
Well ... not a spring chicken
Erdvilla is still on the throne and addrr is progressing at the speed of light