Help me identify 5 coins | 1 to go [solved]

22 posts

» Quick access to the last post

Hello. Yesterday i got 5 new silver coins and I need a little help identifying them.

First coin - 20 Kuruş - Abdülḥamīd II (1876 - Ottoman Empire)
I only know that it is from Ottoman Empire. It's silver, 37 mm in diameter and (i'm just guessing this) about 30 grams. Year 1293 (Islamic year)
I think that it is this coin but I'm not so sure. here's the photo.



Second coin - 3 Grosze - Zygmunt III Olkusz mint (1594 - Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth)
I don't know anything about this coin. I have 2 of theese



Third coin
This one is in bad condition. I'm guessing that it's made out of copper.



Fourth coin - Antoninianus - Gordianus III FORTVNA REDVX (242-244 - Rome (ancient))
I don't know anything about this coin.



Fifth coin - 3 Grosze - Zygmunt III Bydgoszcz mint (1596 - Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth)
This coin is simillar to the second, but they are different.





Thank you all in advance for your help.
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Sorry, I made the wrong ID
Quote: "@josephjk"​Sorry, I made the wrong ID
​No prob
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
2nd and 5th coins are from Poland. Sigismund III (1587-1632)

I'd say coin 1 is 1293 (1876) 1
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces62678.html
? Format  Format  Format ?   ?
Do not argue with ignorant people .. !! They will drag you down to their level, then pulverize you with experience ...
Quote: "derf"
​I'd say coin 1 is 1293 (1876) 1
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces62678.html
​I thought it was the 5 Qirsh too till I saw the weight MihajloNesic posted... it's almost 30 grams...
Quote: "MihajloNesic"First coin - 20 Kuruș - Murad V (1876 - Ottoman Empire)
​I only know that it is from Ottoman Empire. It's silver, 37 mm in diameter and (i'm just guessing this) about 30 grams. Year 1293 (Islamic year)
​I think that it is this coin but I'm not so sure. here's the photo.


​Edit: I think that it's this one: 20 Kuruș - Murad V
(It matches the year, orientation, diameter, weight, thickness)



This is wrong. Your first choice was the correct one. It's not the 20 piastres from Murad V, but the 20 piastres from Abdul Hamid II. Your mistake is understandable. Murad V reigned less then a year in AH1293/AD1876. So the accession date on his coins is 1293 and the regnal year is 1. Abdul Hamid II reigned from AH1293-1327/AD1876-1909. So the accession date on his coins was also 1293 and the coins of his first year of reign have regnal date 1, just like on the Murad V coins. Weight and diameter for both 20 piastres coins were also the same.

BUT: The 20 piastres coin of Murad V has no flower right of the toughra, the 20 piastres coin of Abdul Hamid II does have a flower right of the toughra (like your coin!).

A good advice: when you think you have identified a coin but it's stated as "rare", double check the identification. Allthough we all want to find an unexpected "rare" coin for our collections, most of the time it is "rare" for a reason. So there is a big chance we've just misidentified the coin (unless of course we paid the price of a "rare" coin).
Coins number 2 and 5 are 3 Gröscher/Grosze (Trojak) of Sigismund III Vasa (1587-1632).

Check https://www.pecunem.com/auction-20/lot-1052 or http://amadiocoins.com/catalog/coin/5540
Quote: "derf"​​I'd say coin 1 is 1293 (1876) 1
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces62678.html
​But it's almost 30 grams (27 i think, i dont have the scale)
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Quote: "Essor Prof"
Quote: "MihajloNesic"First coin - 20 Kuruș - Murad V (1876 - Ottoman Empire)
​​I only know that it is from Ottoman Empire. It's silver, 37 mm in diameter and (i'm just guessing this) about 30 grams. Year 1293 (Islamic year)
​​I think that it is this coin but I'm not so sure. here's the photo.
​​
​​
​​Edit: I think that it's this one: 20 Kuruș - Murad V
​​(It matches the year, orientation, diameter, weight, thickness)



​This is wrong. Your first choice was the correct one. It's not the 20 piastres from Murad V, but the 20 piastres from Abdul Hamid II. Your mistake is understandable. Murad V reigned less then a year in AH1293/AD1876. So the accession date on his coins is 1293 and the regnal year is 1. Abdul Hamid II reigned from AH1293-1327/AD1876-1909. So the accession date on his coins was also 1293 and the coins of his first year of reign have regnal date 1, just like on the Murad V coins. Weight and diameter for both 20 piastres coins were also the same.

BUT: The 20 piastres coin of Murad V has no flower right of the toughra, the 20 piastres coin of Abdul Hamid II does have a flower right of the toughra (like your coin!).

​A good advice: when you think you have identified a coin but it's stated as "rare", double check the identification. Allthough we all want to find an unexpected "rare" coin for our collections, most of the time it is "rare" for a reason. So there is a big chance we've just misidentified the coin (unless of course we paid the price of a "rare" coin).
​What about the orientation? It matches the Murad V coin (Medal alignment ↑↑)
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Quote: "MihajloNesic"What about the orientation? It matches the Murad V coin (Medal alignment ↑↑)
The orientation of a coin is just a click in a checkbox, so a mistake is easily made. But wether or not a flower right of the toughra never lies.
Besides a coin alignment for a coin normally with medal alignment and vice versa is not uncommon.
I'm sorry for you, but your coin is a Murad V.

There are a few members who have that Murad V coin, and a few more who have the Abdul Hamid II coin. So you can search who has these coins and send them a message to check which orientation their coins have. But again, that flower doesn't lie.
Quote: "Essor Prof"=1em​I'm sorry for you, but your coin is a Murad V.
Did you ment Abdul Hamid II? Thank you BTW. I'll mark it Abdülḥamīd II for now, but I'm still confused.

My coin HAS a flower but the orientation is ↑↑
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Fourth coin appears to be a Gordian, but I don't have my Sear book handy. I'm sure we can get it, but it may take me a while.
A smart man learns from his mistakes.  A smarter man learns from someone else's.
Quote: "Kurt53"​Fourth coin appears to be a Gordian, but I don't have my Sear book handy. I'm sure we can get it, but it may take me a while.
​It could be this one or this
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
I think that it's second one
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces36823.html
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
The 4th one looks like this one

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces72890.html
Quote: "Essor Prof"I'm sorry for you, but your coin is a Murad V.
I'm so sorry, of course I meant your coin is a Abdul Hamid II (because of the flower).
# 4 may be this one:
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces66125.html
Quote: "neilithic"​The 4th one looks like this one

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces72890.html
​No. The lettering on the front doesn't match. It should be IMP GORDIANVS PIVS FEL AVG
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Yes, Deandemos seems to have it right
Quote: "deandemos"​# 4 may be this one:
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces66125.html


​It mathces the lettering and the back shape (the chair). But the portrait is a little different from my. I could be that one.
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Quote: "D_R"​Coins number 2 and 5 are 3 Gröscher/Grosze (Trojak) of Sigismund III Vasa (1587-1632).

​Check https://www.pecunem.com/auction-20/lot-1052 or http://amadiocoins.com/catalog/coin/5540
​Thank you, this helped a lot!
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/
Quote: "neilithic"​Yes, Deandemos seems to have it right

​Yep. I added it in my collection
https://mnesiccoins.gitlab.io/    https://www.instagram.com/mnesiccoins/

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 04:20.