merge 2 same issuers of sindh

7 posts • viewed 57 times

This message aims at: requesting the creation or the modification of an issuer in the catalogue

Status: Rejected
Upvotes: 1
Downvotes: 0

Merge these 2, they have the same rulers and they are both of the sindh sultanate

in the merge keep the rulers of the Qarlughid dynasty.

Sultanate of Sindh

 

Qarlughid dynasty

Arnav

please consider @tdziemia 

Arnav

Coinwalla

please consider @tdziemia

Please be patient, and don't ping an administrator unless there is an emergency. There are older valid requests than yours which haven't been addressed, and the administrators have many issues to deal with.

@Jarcek @tdziemia @sujit_kumar can we finish this, thanks 

Arnav

The only reference I have for this area is Album, 3d edition.

 

Album has “Sultans of Sind (successor to Ghurids in Sind)” covering only a few jitals coins struck in Sind under the two rulers :

  • Nair al-Din Qubacha (c.1203-1228) types A-1810 to A-1812 and Tye 205, 206, 322
  • Sharif (or Shalif) Beg ( after 1223) types 
  • Types A-1810 to A-1812 and Tye 205, 206, 322
  • Numista has these coins in India > Indian Sultanates > Sind

 

Album has “Qarlughids” in Ghazna and Sind, covering both silver and bronze coins under these rulers:

  • al-Hasan Qarlugh (1224-1249)
  • Nair al-Din Muhammad Qubacha (1249-1259)
  • Types A-1813 to A-1818 and Tye 344-350 for the jitals
  • Numista has these coins in Islamic States >  Qarlughid Dynasty

 

I think the current Numista model follows Album precisely on separating the coins between these two sub-issuers, and that the split into two different top level issuers is acceptable based our geography guidelines.

 

So I think we leave it as is, but I will eliminate one duplicate I see, and if there are mistakes in names of the ruling authorities, I will adjust them.

Status changed to Rejected (tdziemia, 15 Jan 2026, 22:25)

I believe that the rulers of each issuer are mismatched and this was the reason for believing that they were the same issuer

Arnav

Yes, that is understandable.

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 14:22.