French India [solved]

6 posts • viewed 54 times

This message aims at: requesting the creation or the modification of a ruling authority

Status: Done
Upvotes: 1
Downvotes: 1

While creating a ruling authority called “French Settlements” is appropriate, it still complicates things. French India coins sometimes bear symbols of the French Monarchy, such as this: N#113454 and there's many examples. The thing is, French India was recognised as a colony of France/overseas territory. I don't see why there shouldn't be a monarch as ruling authority if it is a colonial possession. Let us have a look at another example, which is, the EIC. The British Crown had no direct involvement in the coins minted by the EIC. However, in Numista, EIC coins have English monarchs as ruling authority which doesn't make sense as the FEIC/French India was much more closely related to the crown. The French East India Company was heavily influenced by the Crown and had less autonomy than BEIC. I don't see a reason why there shouldn't be a French Monarch as the ruling authority of the coins with respect to their ruling years. Although, this is just a suggestion, “French Settlements” is still very appropriate for a ruling authority.

 

TL:DR: French India should have Monarchs as ruling authorities just like British Monarchs do under EIC period (before 1858). 

- x72 -

I personnally don't think it brings any value to the catalogue to simply infer an information from date ranges.

If I'm not wrong, kings are never named or represented themselves on those coins.

It's the same for EIC coins

- x72 -

Maybe but it's not a relevant argument from my perspective; Numista database has errors and incinsistencies regarding its very guidelines, we want to reduce them not let them grow due to mimic ;-)

Then we should make the same changes for the EIC catalogue in my opinion :)

- x72 -

Compendium

Maybe but it's not a relevant argument from my perspective; Numista database has errors and incinsistencies regarding its very guidelines, we want to reduce them not let them grow due to mimic ;-)

Fair, i invalidate this forum post myself as we shouldn't mimic errors. Actually, there should be a forum post about making an EIC ruling authority

- x72 -
Status changed to Done (Jarcek, 26 Jun 2025, 09:40)

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 21:13.