New listing stuck in Narnia...

Recently I tried to add a new listing: N#460717

I was listing 2 very similar 1599 coins, my own and one from a website (with permission, as I understand). In one of them the bottom lion is surrounded with a weapon shield, while in the other the lion is surrounded with an oval shield, so I created 2 year lines, one for each type or variety (depending on interpretation).

A referee asked me to modify it, in order to create another listing for the oval case as a separate type. After removing a year line, things went wrong. There are 3 year lines now, 1599, 1600 and a questionmark that I can't get rid of. The referee cannot find the listing anymore and I don't know how to adjust it properly now. The listing remains hidden for referees it seems, still listed in ‘My modification requests’ with the note ‘Modifications requested’…

E. Timmermans

The listing remains hidden for referees it seems, still listed in ‘My modification requests’ with the note ‘Modifications requested’…

You must edit your request and submit it again. Then the referee will see your request.

@Xavier Maybe the referees should see the requests with status “Modifications requested”. Although these requests are waiting the response for the contributor, the referees will see them.

davidhs

E. Timmermans

The listing remains hidden for referees it seems, still listed in ‘My modification requests’ with the note ‘Modifications requested’…

You must edit your request and submit it again. Then the referee will see your request.

 

@Xavier Maybe the referees should see the requests with status “Modifications requested”. Although these requests are waiting the response for the contributor, the referees will see them.

I already modified it, but after that the referee involved could not find it. Currently it is shown in the modified status when I look at my request.

Besides that, I'm fine with either choice to make separate types or to consider them varieties, here for comparism, my own coin has a similar obverse to the 1600 coin, the 1599 one on the left has the oval shield:

E. Timmermans

I already modified it, but after that the referee involved could not find it. Currently it is shown in the modified status when I look at my request.

In this case I do not know what happened. We wait an admin read this.

The part of ‘lost in Narnia’ is resolved, I didn't realize that after submitting the requested changes I had to click on submit again…

The issue that remains is that the version that I get to see myself (but not available to anyone else) shows the first year line as a questionmark still. When this issue remains after the listing has been approved, then I'll drop another note here, otherwise I'll click on ‘resolved’.

E. Timmermans

The issue that remains is that the version that I get to see myself (but not available to anyone else) shows the first year line as a questionmark still. When this issue remains after the listing has been approved, then I'll drop another note here, otherwise I'll click on ‘resolved’.

When all will be approved, if you need move, edit or remove year lines, the best is post a specific request in the forum “Numista coin catalog” https://en.numista.com/forum/forum14.html with type “requesting the modification of a coin in the catalog”.