Merge Iraqi 500Fils and 500Filsan [solved]

7 posts • viewed 96 times

This message aims at: requesting the modification of a coin in the catalogue

Status: Done
Upvotes: 1
Downvotes: 3

» Quick access to the last post

Hello, since now we can have reference in the year line, can we please merge 500 Fils (Lion-Monument, "Fils")  and 500 Fils (Lion-Monument, "Filsan")  together in one page with lines referenced KM168 and KM168a respectively. Both coins already have the same material, dimensions and design, the only difference is the spelling of the word Fils. 
 

Referee for: Egypt

Similarly 500 Fils 1402 (1982)and 500 Fils (فلساً error) 1402 (1982)  they can be merged as well in one page and have ref KM165 and KM165a respectively, both have the same material, size, weight and design 

Referee for: Egypt
Status changed to Rejected (Jarcek, 18 Mar 2025, 10:04)

Guidelines say to split on different legends. https://en.numista.com/help/coin-types-145.html 
 

Catalogue administrator

I understand, but this is not a different legend —it's the same word with just one extra letter at the end. It's similar to how English adds an 's' for plurals, but the core word remains unchanged. It does not follow the examples in the guide lines like penny and new penny. that's why KM  gave them the same number and considered them as a variety rather than a different design. 

ف ل س   vs  ف  ل س اً  the اً  is very similar to (S). 

Referee for: Egypt
Status changed to Opened (Jarcek, 18 Mar 2025, 14:06)

Ok, could you prepare new yearlines on the page that is suppossed to remain (with explanatory comments), so I can move the users?

Catalogue administrator

Thank you Jarek, 

I just submitted a request to add line for  فلساً  in the  فلس  pages, 500 Fils 1402 (1982)  & 500 Fils (Lion-Monument, "Fils") 1402 (1982) 

The following pages are the ones that need to be merged to the above ones 500 Fils (فلساً error) 1402 (1982)  and 500 Fils (Lion-Monument, "Filsan") 1402 (1982)  respectively.

Thank you

Referee for: Egypt

OK.  All collections, moved.

Thank you.

Status changed to Done (tdziemia, 2 Apr 2025, 04:15)

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 21:03.