Suggestion for image attribution

8 posts • viewed 85 times

This topic was posted in the Francuski forum.

This message aims at: suggesting an idea to improve Numista

Set another member as the source of a picture
Status: Opened
Upvotes: 6
Downvotes: 1

Hello,

 

I suggest adding the option to attribute an image source as "The picture comes from another Numista member."

 

Sometimes, members send me pictures via private messages, or I retrieve images from the forum where members have posted but do not have the time or desire to add an item to the catalog. I also sometimes restore images belonging to Numista members in the history of a page (in the event of a handling error when changing an image). This option would be useful in such situations. We could add it under "other sources," but the link would not redirect to the specific member in question.

Unus pro omnibus, omnes pro uno

What I do in those situations is to put Myself as source and changing pseudo to the fellow Numista member

But in that case the link goes back to your profile?

Unus pro omnibus, omnes pro uno

I think this is long overdue, all referees should have the option to specify a member name as the image source, as images often get messaged, or copied from forum posts… or moved to/from examples. Or inadvertently replaced and you need to go back to an image from ‘modifications history’.

Compendium

What I do in those situations is to put Myself as source and changing pseudo to the fellow Numista member

Also do this currently, but it's less than ideal.

Basteros

But in that case the link goes back to your profile?

It also completely disregards the members ‘specified licence’ choice.

…and also puts the image on your catalogue pictures list, not on their list.

-Dan

Basteros

But in that case the link goes back to your profile?

Yed indeed its just a trick, waiting for the feature :-)

And the copyright clause is the no longer needed? I'm surprised.

Globetrotter
Coin varieties in French:
https://monnaiesetvarietes.numista.com

Sjoelund

And the copyright clause is the no longer needed? I'm surprised.

We are talking about members who have themselves given permission to use their pictures. Implementing this option means that members can be credited in the situations described above instead of putting them in ‘other sources’. We did not say that copyright was no longer necessary. 

Unus pro omnibus, omnes pro uno

I only put my nickname as an image source when I am the author
when it comes from another member I put their nickname with “The picture comes from somewhere else”
In “My catalog pictures” I find images without copyright or with the copyright of other members, ... or from authorized external sites!
This problem has already been reported on the forum at the time of creation of this page

BOINC

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 19:27.