Which country has it the best for commemoratives?

44 posts

» Quick access to the last post

To me it's either Belarus or Poland! I was looking through the catalog and there were soooooooooooooooooooooo many and went to their Mint website and they have A LOT more!

http://www.nbrb.by/engl/CoinsBanknotes/

categories are on the left, but which countries do you guys think that they have it the best on commemoratives wise?

Moved by ZacUK from Numismatic questions to Free discussion
Canada.
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
Well if you're talking about who floods the market with crap coins,

Liberia and DPRK. They issue thousands every year, no joke.
Kenny

- Verifying your Asian and British-territorial coins everyday with the best quality photos and the best information.

Check out my Facebook, Kenneth Gucyski.
Canada has world reconition on comms
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
Canada, I've recently seen some ice hockey ones with red maple leaves which are just amazing ! However the uk does produce some decent stuff too namely the Olympic ones most recently !
mmm, uk ones r awesome

canada produced the world's first colored circulating coin

uk has had commemoratives since the medieval ages tho :D
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
Yeah my girlfriends just bought me an 1806 bahama penny for xmas which was the first colonial commemorative, for captain woodes rogers who was sent in 1716 to expel the pirates of the Caribbean by which ever means he deemed fit which he did by 1717 and also killing Blackbeard however eventually Britain stopped sending supplies and neglected him and the islanders. This must have verb their way of saying sorry "/
Quote: Mark240590Yeah my girlfriends just bought me an 1806 bahama penny for xmas
lol, multiple gfs? its not xmas yet either...

but thats amazing, colonial comm in 1806 :P :D  <:D
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
I'm quite jealous of Canada's $20 for $20 program. You give the mint $20 and a few cents for shipping then they send you a silver proof commemorative coin with a $20 face value. I tried doing that in the States, but it costs me like $17 in shipping. :(
Free thinkers only thrive in history books.
~ Bayside - Howard
Quote: TheShrimpVendorI'm quite jealous of Canada's $20 for $20 program. You give the mint $20 and a few cents for shipping then they send you a silver proof commemorative coin with a $20 face value. I tried doing that in the States, but it costs me like $17 in shipping. :(
i get shipping free because imma member :D

yes, the 20 for 20 is great here in canada
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
That's pretty cool ! However the coloured circulating coins are my fav !
love that profile pic Mark240590, love it

how much is it?
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
I think Switzerland has lovely commemoratives.
there was one on ebay.com a few days ago sold for $150 in what in would have said is VF thats probably fine and it was £25 got it for xmas off the mrs !
nice!
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
yeah its got a few rim dents and that but come on look at the age of it plus imo sometimes things like that add to the beauty !
Definitely!
University is time consuming, cherish your free time!

Honi soit qui mal y pense.
I would say it has to be Canada for sure though I just can't believe coloured coins circulate and I've always loved the red maple leaf that looks amazing on a silver coin ! every now and then the Canadian Air Force do a tour of England. about 4 years ago I was working on a building site and all of a sudden we heard jets and heavy twin propelled helicopters we looked up and there was 2 different jets and 3 choppers all displaying the maple leaf underneath. The helicopters landed on the fields opposite !  Was a pretty cool experience. I think Canada's mint produce such nice coins; because it's a lot smaller than the US so they can - where it would cost daft amounts to do this in America and the UK is so expensive it's probably not that viable here either..the only UK commemorative coinage I have took out of circulation because of how cool they are is the Olympics series 50 pence pieces and the 1994 chunky 50 pence commemorating d-day that I took out of circulation when I was 4 !
For me, Latvia has the best commemoratives, Switzerland is very nice too.
I think Australia has great commemoratives.  Especially the 50c series.
Which country has it best for commemoratives? Whichever one has the least. In my opinion anyway :~
Canada and Australia
We have a load of very nice commemoratives due next year as it's the 60th anniversary of the Coronation.
I would say UK & Isle of Man, I.O.M. has an amazing selection of crowns.
The only commemoratives I've ever seen which didn't inspire the gag reflex are the US 1/2 dollars from the inter-war years.

Unfortunately except for the Booker T one they are quite expensive. I'm wanting the Stone Mountain for Christmas.
Non illegitimis carborundum est.  Excellent advice for all coins.
Make Numismatics Great Again!  
For me it's Thailand - great coins and cheap to get in Thailand.

I just got about 20 new ones all for face value from the local Thai town hall.
I think pnightingale has it right as far as the best commemorative series... It's the old USA half dollars . Best country for commemoratives now is Canada...our neighbors to the north have created a lot of beautiful well-themed coins!
Hi all,

For me, it's Russia, or should I say URSS.
I love the 1 Rouble series coins from  1965 until 1991, I also love the 3 and 5 Rouble ones, and the Russian coins after 1991 are also great.

About Polish coins, they are just good. Too many coins per year.  ;(  A guy lost the interest of it. I have about 100 coins of 2 Zloty and it's insane.

Belarus have also some lovely coins, and of course Portugal have some good coins too. (eheheh)

Portugal have 11 series of 4 coins each that talk abouth discovery time. They are a great piece of Portuguese history told by coins.  B)


Cheers
HR
Carpe Diem - HR
Being a collector of older coins, I don't have much choice.

1. Bavaria
2. German 2, 3, and 5 marks state issues under empire
3. Tsarist Russia

There's not much else... :(
Truth is it depends on your upbringing and parenthood.
Me UK rubbish for commemoratives, in my opinion, apart from odd one.
Merry Christmas to you all, & definitely Happy New Year.
Overall, I agree that the US has the best commemorative coins. As pnightingale said, the inter-war half dollars are very nice, but too expensive for me. More recently, I love that they are issuing pairs of coins, the silver dollar and the clad half. And also that, unlike the UK and Canada, they can use the obverse for commemoration as well.
Catalogue referee for British, English and Scottish coins.

Le référent pour des pièces britannique, anglais et écossais.
I think Italian lira comm. coins were the best - but also San Marino !
Eendragt maakt magt
As an Australian, I'm probably giving a biased answer but here goes...
Australia's Perth Mint
I'll give the following reasons:
  • Limited mintage
  • All coins (including standard bullion issues) come in mint issue capsules
  • Consistent great designs
  • High demand from both numismatic & investment sectors
As I say, I'm biased though...
The Perth Mint also mints so beautiful commemorative coins on behalf of smaller Island Nations like Tuvalu which are possibly even nicer than their Australian counterparts..
Like I say, just my own (biased) opinion!
     TheBullionBoys International Ltd.
                  World Class Bullion
  Specialists in: Hand Poured & Stamped
 Gold & Silver Bullion Bars, Rare & Vintage
                Coins, Bars & Rounds
There are so many countries with beautiful comm. coins - but I would choose Thailand 'cos it's easy to find them with face value. By the way I could do many swaps by using 1-2-5-10-20 baht comm. coins, they have many types for each unit... Great...
Quote: tony_k_1965I would say UK & Isle of Man, I.O.M. has an amazing selection of crowns.
I gotta agree with you there, my second & third choices would be the U.K. Gold & Silver Britannia coins & then the Isle of Man & Guernsey 4 & 8 "Doubles" :)
     TheBullionBoys International Ltd.
                  World Class Bullion
  Specialists in: Hand Poured & Stamped
 Gold & Silver Bullion Bars, Rare & Vintage
                Coins, Bars & Rounds
I like Poland 2 zl commemoratives. Not big problem to find, many themes (animals, culture, buildings, ships, history...)
For me it's Belarus Proof coins. They are just lovely. Second would USA "America the Beautiful" series.
“A man without a hobby is only half alive.”
Franklin Delano Roosevelt
I would say the US (totally no bias). The state quarter series helps kids learn for having to label the map in school, and there are some beautiful designs.
Quote: "KennyG"​Well if you're talking about who floods the market with crap coins,

​Liberia and DPRK. They issue thousands every year, no joke.
cough cough Niue cough cough Cook Islands cough cough
Quote: "fatbardhshpuza"​I think Italian lira comm. coins were the best - but also San Marino !
​The old Italian commemoratives were certainly beautiful. The best are the extremely rare pre-1946 NCLTs in my opinion. Stunning designs!
Quote: "GoldenGarfield"
Quote: "KennyG"​Well if you're talking about who floods the market with crap coins,
​​
​​Liberia and DPRK. They issue thousands every year, no joke.
​​cough cough Niue cough cough Cook Islands cough cough
​cough cough Solomon Islands, cough Newzealand cough cough cough British antarctic territories cough South gerorgia and Sandwich Islands cough cough
Quote: "15turtles"​Canada has world reconition on comms
​Canada they just do it best, like there coloured coins and olympic coin is what got me into it
I really appreciate the coin-issuing-policy from Nigeria...
...you can run,  but you can't hide...
A few UK commemoratives are beautiful and thoughtful, but the majority (especially the £5 crowns) just seem like they crank them out en masse for profit. Gibraltar’s crown series is also a huge cash grab designed to be peddled by scummy companies with formal and pompous names like ‘the Westminster collection’ and ‘the Bradford exchange’.

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 00:55.