This question has bothered me since last night after watching those "cleaning coin" vids on Youtube, and I googled the same question; with no solid answer in sight. When is the right time to replace those coin holders or capsules (regardless of the brand), 2 to 5 years later, 10 years later? I know coins age inevitably and that nothing lasts forever, but what are some techniques or methods that you use to prevent early oxidation or tarnish? Let me know.