I want to universal page about "wire money"

I want to universal page like Mikhail I:https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces17466.html

I think it would be good to have a universal page for each emperor. What do you all think?

The engravings are often incomplete, so I honestly think it's difficult to identify.

It would be fine to have,,,

1.a page for each emperor...would be that they could temporarily collect money by emperor.

2.it could be universal as wire money…would be that they could register even if they couldn't even identify the emperor.

Hi

nice innovation :-)

Nevertheless, I believe we should not create Numista type pages for coins we cannot sort correctly. It would potentially pollute the entire catalog

I think when you have such coin in your collection you should chose one existing type and add your coin as “undetermined” yearline

WDYT @Xavier  @Jarcek  @tdziemia  @Grinya ?

I tend to agree that if the catalog is now set up with much detail for these types, but a member is not sure of the correct type for their coin due to some missing detail, the best approach is to post the coin on the forum to get an opinion on the nearest match, and then use the “Undetermined” feature.

I would like a page like Michael I's for the current situation.

 They are kind enough to consider and offer specific help, which is great.

 However, I think a universal page would be very useful if the grade is bad or no specific solution can be found.

Or reclassify it on the individual emperor pages. As things stand, if it is not identified, the UNK will become an inappropriate UNK.

My wish is not to have it be just a universal page for each emperor.
I want it to be a last resort for everyone. It's not always possible to categorize it.
A page like Michael I's may be inappropriate. But if it can help everyone, then I think it has value.
I don't know how it ended up being just for Michael I, but I think it's still useful.

Personally, my greatest wish would be to modify the Michael I page and turn it into a universal page for all wire money. In that case, it would be wire money, but even the emperor would be unidentifiable, and you would still be able to register it.

For this situation this page exists

N#43609

You can add a yearline for wire money and register unidentified coins

I am aware of this too.

 If that's the case, we don't need Michael I's Universal. If there's one, wouldn't it be nice to have others too? This overlaps a bit with what you said at the beginning.

If we can identify the coin but are not sure of the year, mint and etc, I think we should register the coin as unknown on that page.

You are right I moved Michael I kopecks as yearline in the unidentified coin generic page 

I think it would have been better to make one universal page for all Russian wire coins using that existed page for Michael coin and use one yearline per ruler… But another decision was implemented…

You made the decision too quickly... The opinions are evenly split. The discussion is too shallow.

It would be best to update the page. Can't you revive it and remake?

It's sad that it's registered as UNK even though the country and coin are specified.

Grinya

I think it would have been better to make one universal page for all Russian wire coins using that existed page for Michael coin and use one yearline per ruler… But another decision was implemented…

I think this way is the best for Numista

Then you can submit an idea to improve Numista in the corresponding section of the forum :-)

In this section, I apply guidelines my best